The Spreadsheet Trap: Why Managing Teams in Excel is Holding You Back
Jan 5, 2025
Orlando Osorio, Cofounder @ Supervisible
Every day, countless teams rely on spreadsheets to plan their work. It's familiar, it's available, and it seems to get the job done. But at what cost? Let's dive into why spreadsheets are becoming the biggest obstacle to effective team planning.
The False Comfort of Spreadsheets
We get it. Spreadsheets feel safe. They've been your trusted companion for years. But like that old coffee machine in the office, just because something's always been there doesn't mean it's serving you well.
The Real Costs of Spreadsheet Dependency
1. Time Drain
Hours spent updating formulas
Manual data entry errors
Constant maintenance of linked sheets
Version control nightmares
"Who has the latest version?" syndrome
2. Hidden Costs
Lost productivity from outdated information
Missed opportunities due to unclear capacity
Team burnout from poor workload visibility
Decision delays waiting for updated data
The endless "can you share the sheet?" emails
3. The Human Cost
Remember when your team member took on too many projects because three different spreadsheets showed different availability? Or when someone pulled an all-nighter because capacity planning was out of date?
Signs You've Outgrown Spreadsheets
Your team spends more time updating sheets than doing actual work
You can't quickly answer "Do we have capacity for this project?"
Team members are either overloaded or underutilized
Planning meetings turn into spreadsheet debugging sessions
You've caught yourself saying "The formula must be broken"
Why Spreadsheets Fail Modern Teams
They're Static in a Dynamic World
Work patterns change daily
Client needs fluctuate
Teams need real-time insights
They're One-Dimensional
Can't capture the complexity of modern work
Miss important context
Lack predictive capabilities
They're Not Built for Collaboration
Limited real-time updates
Poor visibility across teams
No built-in communication tools
The Way Forward: Modern Team Planning
What if instead of managing spreadsheets, you could:
See team capacity at a glance
Make informed decisions in real-time
Prevent burnout before it happens
Align work with team capabilities
Focus on people, not cells
Breaking Free from the Spreadsheet Cycle
The first step is acknowledging that while spreadsheets are comfortable, they're holding your team back. Modern work requires:
Real-time visibility
Intelligent work distribution
Burnout prevention
Cross-team collaboration
Human-first planning
The Cost of Not Changing
Every day you stick with spreadsheets is:
Another day of manual updates
Another risk of version conflicts
Another missed opportunity for better planning
Another step toward team burnout
Another barrier to growth
Embracing Change
Moving beyond spreadsheets isn't just about adopting new tools – it's about embracing a better way of working. One where:
Teams have clear visibility into their work
Managers make informed decisions
Work gets distributed fairly
People are treated like humans, not numbers
It's Time to Evolve
Your team deserves better than being managed in cells and columns. They deserve tools that:
Respect their time
Support their best work
Prevent burnout
Enable growth
Put humans first
Ready to break free from the spreadsheet trap?
About the Author
Orlando is the Cofounder of Supervisible, a human-first team planning platform transforming how modern teams work together. Previously founded Meaningful, helping tech companies like Medium, Robinhood, and BetterUp achieve growth through SEO and CRO. Venture partner at 0BS and LP at 500 Startups.
Founded multiple companies and participated in top accelerators including MassChallenge and Startup Chile. Backed by Michael Seibel (former CEO of Y Combinator). Former strategic planning lead at Coca-Cola.